Shortcuts
Tags
Latest Posts
Shunt Resistor versus Hall Effect Technology
![Shunt Resistor versus Hall Effect Technology](https://www.knick-international.com/media/57/c7/51/1712830007/Shunt%20Resistor%20versus%20Hall%20Effect%20Technology_900x765.webp)
Measurement of Large DC Currents
There are many systems where measurement of large DC currents are needed for performance and safety. Two examples are static excitation and rail traction power. These current measurements are often made by one of two main principles: shunt resistor with mV transducer or Hall effect feed-through sensor.
Both sensor principles have existed for decades. For this reason, commercially available sensors of both principles can be regarded as time proven. However, each have their pros and cons, and are mainly tied to the physics of the principle used. If the disadvantage of a sensor is inherently bound to its physics, it is hard or impossible to overcome the problem, regardless of the number of iterations or design changes it has gone through.
If accuracy of the measurement is of particular importance, shunt resistor designs have relevant advantages. Even with documented accuracy specifications, far-field influences of neighboring conductors and sensor position make it almost impossible to assess the total measurement error of a non-contact Hall sensor.
However, if size minimization is necessary for an installation, then Hall effect sensors, with an overall smaller total footprint, could be considered. This is due to shunt measurement requiring a two-piece system, the shunt resistor, which would have a footprint directly proportional to the amount of current being measured, coupled with a corresponding mV transducer.
Conclusion
If ensuring accuracy with current measurements is of primary importance, then a shunt resistor with a corresponding mV transducer is likely the best option to consider. Due to the effects of various external influences such as temperature, positioning of sensor and conductor, stability and coupling of auxiliary power supply, and high current events that might be eventually seen, the initial and sustained accuracy of Hall effect sensors is very difficult to assess.
If other considerations within an application outweigh the benefits of accuracy seen with a shunt and mV transducer package, then Hall effect sensors could be further evaluated. This might include a project where space is limited to incorporate a shunt, and where this available space might heat up if a shunt were to be housed within it, due to power dissipation.
However, convenience with the installation and downstream maintenance should also enter into decision making. Here, the shunt and mV transducer show further advantages, due to compatibility with standard control systems, and ease with initial mounting and potential replacement.
The following chart offers a further comparison of the two technologies, with advantages for each technology highlighted in green, accordingly.
![ShuntVHall_Together a table comparing shunt resistors to hall effect sensors with regard to typical current measurements](https://www.knick-international.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ShuntVHall_Together.jpg.webp)
![Steve Allard](https://www.knick-international.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Steve-Allard.jpg.webp)
Steve Allard
General Manager at Knick Interface LLC, USA
Phone: +1 888 62 KNICK
Latest Posts
Process Analytics
Uniclean700, Launch
Knick GmbH Company | Interface Technology | Process Analytics
Process Analytics
Launch, Fitting, WA111
Process Analytics
Launch, Fitting, WA155
Process Analytics
Phamacy, pH, Conductivity
Related Posts
![InnoTrans 2022 - three products as world firsts for rolling stock and DC traction power supply applications](https://www.knick-international.com/media/f0/46/9b/1712818184/Knick-Innotrans-2022_900x675.jpg)
Sep 2022
Interface Technology
Exhibition, InnoTrans
InnoTrans 2022 - three products as world firsts for rolling stock and DC traction power supply applications
![Energy storage - the handshake between renewable energy and electric vehicles](https://www.knick-international.com/media/8f/df/0c/1701446176/Knick-energy-storage-900x675.jpg)
May 2022
Interface Technology
Energy
Energy storage - the handshake between renewable energy and electric vehicles
![P52000VPD voltage presence detector reliably detects voltages up to 4200 V DC](https://www.knick-international.com/media/5b/65/e0/1712830007/PR_AL_P52000VPD_Blog_220216_900x675.webp)
Feb 2022
Interface Technology
P52000VPD, Voltage
P52000VPD voltage presence detector reliably detects voltages up to 4200 V DC
![Knick Interface at Battery and Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology Expo](https://www.knick-international.com/media/0e/28/d0/1712830007/Battery-Show-USA-2021_booth-Knick-Interface_900x675.webp)
Sep 2021
Interface Technology
USA, Exhibition
Knick Interface at Battery and Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology Expo
![Quadruple Standard Signals in Just One Signal Conditioner](https://www.knick-international.com/media/12/d3/98/1701451790/Knick-P20340-Quadrupler_900x675.jpg)
May 2021
Interface Technology
Quadruple Standard Signals in Just One Signal Conditioner
![Electrical measurement and process analytics for hydrogen production](https://www.knick-international.com/media/b0/15/8a/1712830007/2021-de-H2-Forum_900_675.webp)
Apr 2021
Interface Technology
Hydrogen
Electrical measurement and process analytics for hydrogen production
![Condition Monitoring of High-Voltage Motors](https://www.knick-international.com/media/e1/59/84/1712830007/High-Voltage-Motors_900x675.webp)
Mar 2021
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer, USA, P44000
Condition Monitoring of High-Voltage Motors
![Pulse frequency conditioner for speed sensors](https://www.knick-international.com/media/c1/0b/94/1712830007/knick-frequency-conditioner-p16000_900x675.webp)
Mar 2021
Interface Technology
Pulse frequency conditioner for speed sensors
![Worldwide smallest transducer up to ±2200 V](https://www.knick-international.com/media/f7/a5/48/1712830007/Blog_P42000D2_Hand_900x675.webp)
Nov 2020
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer, Voltage, P42000D2
Worldwide smallest transducer up to ±2200 V
![Importance of broad-range power supplies for DC electrical measurement](https://www.knick-international.com/media/74/70/27/1712830007/Blog_KI_PowerSupply_900x675.webp)
Aug 2020
Interface Technology
DC
Importance of broad-range power supplies for DC electrical measurement
![Measuring Photovoltaic Degradation](https://www.knick-international.com/media/a1/50/56/1712830007/Photovoltaic_Appl_Productmontage_P29_900x675.webp)
Jul 2020
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer, DC, P29000
Measuring Photovoltaic Degradation
![Electrical Measurement Solutions: Control from 480 to 4800 Volts](https://www.knick-international.com/media/ec/d9/b8/1712830007/Blog_480-4800_900x675.webp)
Jun 2020
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer, USA
Electrical Measurement Solutions: Control from 480 to 4800 Volts
![Benefits of High Voltage Transducers versus Instrument Transformers](https://www.knick-international.com/media/81/53/cd/1712830007/blog-011-p-41000-trms-xx_900.webp)
Jun 2020
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer
Benefits of High Voltage Transducers versus Instrument Transformers
![Shunt Resistor versus Hall Effect Technology](https://www.knick-international.com/media/57/c7/51/1712830007/Shunt%20Resistor%20versus%20Hall%20Effect%20Technology_900x765.webp)
Nov 2019
Interface Technology
DC, USA, Current
Shunt Resistor versus Hall Effect Technology
![MTBF beyond 3000 years: A snap hook for your plant](https://www.knick-international.com/media/c3/e1/50/1712830007/Blog_MTBF_3000_900x675.webp)
Mar 2018
Interface Technology
MTBF beyond 3000 years: A snap hook for your plant
![Knick Products Comply With UL - What Does That Mean?](https://www.knick-international.com/media/6c/44/ae/1712830007/02b_general-approval-UL_IMG_900x675.webp)
Jan 2018
Interface Technology
UL
Knick Products Comply With UL - What Does That Mean?
![High-voltage transducer offers more safety on railway vehicles](https://www.knick-international.com/media/dd/c8/55/1712901356/Blog_Meet_P50000_Series_900x675.webp)
Nov 2017
Interface Technology
High-Voltage Transducer, P50000
High-voltage transducer offers more safety on railway vehicles
![True RMS Measurement with P41000TRMS](https://www.knick-international.com/media/81/53/cd/1712830007/blog-011-p-41000-trms-xx_900.webp)
Feb 2017
Interface Technology
P41000TRMS
True RMS Measurement with P41000TRMS
![Functional safety and maximum availability can go together](https://www.knick-international.com/media/7c/2f/d1/1712830007/blog-005-p-22400-sil-xx_900x675.webp)
Feb 2017
Interface Technology
P22400, SIL